
GTA 6 has a 99 Metascore but only a 4.9 from users on Metacritic
Game Rant says Metacritic users rate GTA 6 4.9 out of 10 while critics give it 99, and calls it review bombing, though it offers no direct evidence.
Metacritic critics give GTA 6 a 99, based on more than 150 reviews, but players are not so generous. According to Game Rant, the user score stood at 4.9 out of 10, labelled Generally Unfavorable, at the time of writing, just after user reviews went live.
Game Rant splits the negative reviews in two. Some complain about the story, the protagonists and the relationship mechanics in terms the site describes as 'woke' or 'DEI' complaints, which it says have nothing to do with how the game plays. Others are more reasonable: that the game is slower, closer to Red Dead Redemption 2 than GTA 5, and more realistic than earlier entries.

The site calls this review bombing, meaning many users leaving negative scores to protest something other than quality, and says it is almost certainly the case, though it offers no direct evidence. It adds that Metacritic restricts user reviews during an early window and that some may be removed. It points to the 99 on OpenCritic, where 99% of critics recommend the game, as the better guide to how it is landing.